1 January 2014

Top 10 films of 2013

Last year I was surprised my films of the year skewed beneath the main Hollywood radar (see that list here). This time I expected it since it's hardly been a vintage year for bigger studio productions, and so again it's mostly a smattering of small indie and foreign films that I connected with the most. But first, for perspective and because I love stats, here are some numbers. In 2013 I watched:

- 246 individual films (only 12 less than the previous year)
- 6 films more than once in the 12 month period
- 96 films at the cinema (39% of total films watched and the first time in 4 years this is sub 100)

If you're vaguely interested, I've again used Letterboxd to keep a list of everything I watched in 2013, in order: http://letterboxd.com/davidhunt14/list/2013-films-watched/

And so, in alphabetical order, these are my top 10 films of 2013. This is not to say they are the "best" films of the year (how do you even quantify that!?), but these are my favourites:

Blue Is the Warmest Colour



Blue Is the Warmest Colour puts love through the wringer. It shows love in all it's resplendent glory, from the excited thrill through to the debilitating loneliness caused but it's loss. This is a girl's journey of self discovery down a road she seemingly wasn't expecting, shot in a realistic and raw style that's redolent of everyday life, ensuring it has an impact. The excellent acting from the two leads, in brave highly-revealing roles, can't be over-stated. It's an entirely engaging film with a core subject matter so prevalent in film-making, that it's amazing so few films manage to recreate it in such an honest way.
[Read my full review here]

The Broken Circle Breakdown



In many ways The Broken Circle Breakdown is the film that emotionally hit me hardest this year. It's a romance shrouded in tragedy that eschews cliché through clever editing, managing to tell the story of a relationship in a multi-layered way forcing you to never be caught up in one emotion for too long. The two leads are fascinating characters with depth, always feeling left of centre and their acting is superb. But what really seals the deal is the application of American country music to this Belgian setting and when the leads perform on stage, the film feels electrifyingly alive. This is a country song brought to life with a satisfying emotional weight.

Cloud Atlas



Cloud Atlas was probably the most audacious attempt at storytelling I saw all year. It's ability to weave six wildly different stories, set across a range of era's from the distant future to the past, is a masterclass in editing as the film continually jumps scene by scene from one thread to the next. Add to this that the same cast feature in all six stories, playing different roles and many times under huge amounts of prosthesis, it remains a fascinating film even if certain elements or stories don't always work. And not forgetting the music - this is a key component in making the film so beguiling, particularly as it reaches a crescendo. A film like very little else this year that's so easy to become lost in.

Ender's Game



This may seem like an unlikely inclusion on an end of year best of list, considering it only reviewed so-so, but something about Ender's Game just thoroughly worked for me. The story follows a direct line, shorn of unnecessary sub-plots that might otherwise distract. Visually it's stunning and may have taken so long to adapt from it's original literary source as it needed modern special effects to be at a requisite standard. But more importantly it's a film with ideas. Ideas about humanity's arrogance and survival instinct. Ideas about what it takes for youth to become both strong and leaders. And for this, alongside the sucker punch ending, it's a film that both excited me and made me think.


The Great Beauty



A film about the beauty of Rome, about aging and living life to the full. The Great Beauty is exuberantly full of life as we follow our protagonist, an aging writer, as he's immersed in the beauty of the city, the women he loves and has loved and wistfully wishing he could get back to that moment of true beauty that escaped his past. It's a film that unexpectedly sneaks up on you, washing over you with a natural insouciance that leads to a seductive experience full of life, comedy and a touch of drama.
[Read my short review here]


Only God Forgives



Staking claim as probably the most divisive film of the year, Only God Forgives is no doubt appearing on as many best-of lists as worst-of. It's the work of a perpetually creative director and one of the hottest stars in the world pulling further into esoteric territory, ensuring desires for Drive part II or something more accessible be damned. It's good to confound expectations and the darkness perpetuating deeply within is uncomfortably intoxicating. It's a metaphorical descent into hell. It's beautifully shot and lit, savagely visceral, makes dramatic use of colour and is accompanied by a score dripping in deleterious portent. All the while the story grips and Ryan Gosling's performance of near wordless moodiness fascinates. Love it or loathe it, this is an undeniably creative and challenging film.
[Read my full review here]


The Place Beyond the Pines



The Place Beyond the Pines may just be my favourite film of the year. An entrancing triptych of interlocking stories, on the surface it's a mixture of bank robbery, police corruption and youth gone wild, but it's what's bubbling underneath that sets it apart. A fascinating study of patriarchs and how their absences and legacies scar their sons - this is the thread that runs throughout, explored in different tangents. But everything coalesces thanks to exhilarating camera work and a moody as hell score, and of course not forgetting the great performances from an excellent cast. This is a fantastic film that delivers confidently on multiple levels and is one that has firmly stayed with me throughout the year.


Spring Breakers



Spring Breakers may be a film quickly dismissed for what it appears to be on the surface - an easy attempt at titillation - but that's a facile viewpoint that only sees stars in bikinis and the carnage caused by spring break exuberance. No, this is a neon-clad nightmare where the pressures and aimlessness of modern youth need escaping from, and where it's easy to get lost seizing power in the most dangerous way possible. Through and through it's entirely off-beat, with snippets of scenes, minimal dialogue (mostly from James Franco in the best of his many roles this year), wild roaming camera work and creative editing that helps tell the story more through feel and experience. It's a Harmony Korine film after all so what else would you expect? This is the multi-layered ennui of modern youth brought to life in the most thrilling way possible.  [Read my full review here]


Upstream Color



Where to even begin with Upstream Color? It's the kind of creative, low budget indie filmmaking that fills the heart with joy. Taking a shifting story that's always opaque, what is clear is that this is portraying a cycle of life and is concerned with existential questions. It's confident work that wants the audience to have to reach and question. There is no straight ahead. Shane Carruth is the auteur, taking on a myriad of roles in the production and again justifying the reverence with which he's held thanks to Primer. This is exhilarating filmmaking on all levels, from the way it's shot and edited, the use of sound, the story and acting. It's unequivocally one of the films of the year.
[Read my full review here]


The Way Way Back



This was something unexpected. The Way Way Back is one of the sweetest journeys of self discovery seen in recent years, set against the backdrop of summer in Cape Cod, a run-down water park and adults who use this place as a way to escape reality. There's the requisite comedy, notably from an excellent Sam Rockwell playing to his strengths, and the drama of a broken family and an awkward youth who doesn't feel like he fits in anywhere. But watching him find himself with Rockwell's tutelage is one of the most dizzyingly heart-warming moments on screen this year in a superbly balanced film.  


Note 1: This list is based on films released in the UK from 1st Jan - 31st Dec, be that a cinema release or direct to DVD/VOD release. Most end of year lists tend to be dominated by the big "award-worthy" films, but as the UK generally doesn't see these films until January / February thanks to BAFTA's rules, it makes UK lists seem weirdly out of step with the US, as Oscar consideration requires at least a week's US theatrical run by 31st Dec. And in case you're wondering, of the films that dominated the 2013 awards season, those I liked best were released in 2012.

Note 2: Reviews are only linked to where I have written one. Unfortunately I don't have time to review everything I watch and sometimes the hardest to write are for the films I like the most.

Note 3: You can see my list of the worst films of 2013 here.

The worst films of 2013

There's a very valid point of view that as a film fan you should be able to find something to like in every film. As happily as that applies most of the time, there will always be films that either don't live up to expectations or you flat out don't like. Regardless of how much you want to celebrate film there's always a need for criticism, and besides, as this is a film blog, it's as useful to understand what the author doesn't like as much as what they do. These then are the films I liked least in 2013, split out as the plain worst and the most disappointing:

The worst films of 2013:

A Field In England



In my review of Sightseers last year (read that here) I commented how director Ben Wheatley has a good visual eye but desperately needs to figure out how to tell a story, and a decent one at that. Yet again he's fallen into the same trap, but this time with a story so inanely boring it's a miracle I stayed with the film for it's duration. The acting here is sub amateur dramatic awful, the writing and story nonsensical and the entire setting just a field, meaning the film is entirely reliant on the aforementioned aspects. The only moments of mild interest appear during a psychedelic visual freak-out that is enhanced by the monochrome cinematography. This year we saw the best thing Wheatley's produced, Unearthed, his exciting and creative few minute long segment in The ABC's of Death. A Field In England is the absolute antithesis - the most lifeless and boring film I've seen in a long time and easily the worst thing "the most over-rated director in Britain" has produced.

A Good Day To Die Hard


I don't think anyone was expecting A Good Day To Die Hard to be a particularly good film, but considering Die Hard 4.0 has some decent elements to it there was proof these films could still work in the modern age. Alas, within the first few minutes it was clear that any hope should be abandoned. The action scenes feel uninspired, the story wrapped around these severely lacking and worst of all, Bruce Willis seems to be lazily sleepwalking his way in front of the camera amidst a range of wooden acting. Under any other name this may have been a barely passable action film, but with the Die Hard name attached it's reduced John McClane and the franchise from the exemplar of the action genre to poorly clichéd, unexciting filmmaking lacking any essence of what made the first three great. No-one wanted to see the Die Hard films end up like this.
[Read my full review here]

The Hangover Part III


The cardinal sin committed by the second Hangover film was replicating the original's story almost exactly beat for beat and making it less funny in every way. Thus shifting the structure of The Hangover Part III's story and returning the Wolf Pack to Vegas was the one wise decision made here (and maybe throwing Melissa McCarthy into the mix too). Alas it made no difference. The story limps from one uninspired set piece to the next and seems to have suffered a humour bypass in the process. In 100 minutes of screen time only two actually funny jokes were spotted, one of which was during the credits. Both Hangover sequels have felt like they're dragging the carcass of something enjoyable and funny into the town square and beating it in the desperate hope something good will come from it. Clearly nothing will. Let's erase these sequels from our minds and keep our fingers crossed that no more ever appear.
[Read my full review here]

Olympus Has Fallen

 
And the award for the most wooden performance of the year goes to Gerard Butler. No wait, that could instead read, and the award for the worst script of the year goes to the team behind Olympus Has Fallen. But should any of that matter with a film like this? Well, when you're trying to root for a hero to save the day and he seems totally stilted; when the tone of the film is all wrong, it begins to matter. Everything is imbued with a savagely violent patriotism that sits uneasily throughout. I'm all for violent action films, but this transcends the fantastical violence of most as a po faced 'Merica jams a knife in the head of it's "enemies". The almost identical White House Down provides much needed perspective, being so well cast and written that it's not only a hell of a lot of fun, as this story should be, it's funny too. Olympus Has Fallen missed that memo as it becomes a laughably bad footnote in the annals of the action genre.

Passion


Over recent months I had the pleasure of watching Blow Out, Dressed To Kill and The Fury (all superbly remastered on bluray by the ever excellent Arrow Video) which show director Brian De Palma at the height of his creative powers in the late seventies and early eighties. Perhaps this helped fuel my distaste for his latest film, Passion. Aside from it starring two leads who are usually much better than this material, everything about the film feels amateur. From the no budget look and feel of the whole picture, the terribly clichéd story rife with moments that just don't work, to the general mis-casting and poor acting throughout (including those two leads). It's confounding seeing De Palma's name attached. As with A Field In England, this is the only other film this year where I had to desperately resist the temptation to turn it off halfway through. And like that film, this was so bad that sticking it out was really really not worth it. 


The most disappointing films of 2013:

Aftershock

 
I should've learnt by now never to trust any film with Eli Roth's involvement, unless it's under the guidance of the estimable Mr Tarantino. Everything he does continually disappoints, yet somehow he wasn't the worst aspect of Aftershock, a film that seemed to be generating great buzz online. Or perhaps I should just stop following Roth on Twitter. A raw and more graphic take on the earthquake movie is a good idea. The Chilean setting adds character. I didn't even mind the build-up where we get to know the characters. But as the film quickly devolves into a survival horror where a bunch of frenzied males only seem concerned with chasing and raping the attractive female protagonists, we're left with such a thoroughly disappointing film that any reason to watch quickly dissipates. Why the filmmakers chose to go this route is an absolute mystery, with all potential from the build up rapidly destroyed.

The Counsellor 

 
Directed by Ridley Scott; written for the screen by critically adored author Cormac McCarthy; starring Michael Fassbender, Javier Bardem, Penelope Cruz, Cameron Diaz and Brad Pitt. Unfortunately no, The Counsellor is not on the wrong list, as this was one of the most squandered opportunities I saw all year. The whole film amounts to a massive "so what". The focus of the story lies in the wrong place so it rapidly becomes boring as scenes that are visually appealing pass before the eyes without any real care about their significance or whatever. It's clear why this fantastic cast wanted to be involved, it's just a shame that talent of the likes of Scott and McCarthy couldn't craft something even vaguely interesting for the viewer.

Star Trek Into Darkness

 
A Star Trek film that ignores the huge potential within it's grasp - surely that should be a crime? I was a big fan of the 2009 Star Trek, it being the kind of film I never wanted to end and would happily have sat through a couple of hours more. Into Darkness had the opposite effect on me - an hour in I couldn't wait for it to be over. It's a sequel trying too hard to be the film preceding it, including replication of certain sequences. It doesn't seem to want to leave either the Enterprise or Earth and serves up a villain big in folkloric potential, but both terribly realised and acted. But the biggest sin - it's lost any sense of wonder by almost entirely ignoring the incredibly rich universe available to it and focusing on a human villain. Not even the dynamic of the characters we know and love can save it. Into Darkness had so much potential to be a great sequel. That it failed so easily is thoroughly disappointing.
[Read my full review here]

Warm Bodies

 
I'm generally not a fan of zombie stories sanitised for a friendlier rating as I want to see viscera ripped by the teeth of the rotting. But strangely that wasn't the issue with Warm Bodies. There's a really intriguing story at it's still heart, something that feels like a neat little twist on the hackneyed zombie tale. Thus it's a shame the actual realisation of this is so inert it feels dead on arrival. It's hard to pin down the exact cause for this infection but a myriad of factors are at play, from the casting and acting, the voiceover, the set design, the lifeless pacing and the fact it all feels so glossy. All the fun was drained from this twitching corpse right from the start and no matter how much electricity was applied, nothing could shock it back to life.

The World's End

 
The appearance of The World's End on this list is less to do with expectations and more to do with over-reactions and wasted potential. I'm of the view that Edgar Wright's best film by a long way is Scott Pilgrim vs the World and that his so-called 'Cornetto trilogy' is comprised of only one decent film. And that isn't The World's End. This is a film deeply mired by characterisation. The lead is one of the most horribly unlikeable I've seen on screen in a long time and he thoroughly overshadows the supporting cast of wholly bland characters who rarely get a chance to stand out. It's a comedy that desperately lacks laughs and the whole story amounts to a tiresome slog despite Wright's usual interesting visual touches and musical savvy. Wright is capable of so much more and this was disappointing to see. That critics and other viewers fawned over this is even more inexplicable.
[Read my full review here]


Note 1: This list is based on films released in the UK from 1st Jan - 31st Dec, be that a cinema release or direct to DVD/VOD release.

Note 2: Reviews are only linked to where I have written one. Unfortunately I don't have time to review everything I watch and although it's fun to write reviews pulling apart films, sometimes it feels unnecessary, or you just want to forget the badness.

Note 3: You can see my top 10 films of 2013 here.

31 December 2013

Review: The Secret Life of Walter Mitty

(Dir: Ben Stiller, 2013)

Comedic actors have a greater tendency than most to become tiresome when they play what is in essence the same role over and over. Take someone like Ben Stiller. In earlier films he was fun to watch but now his presence has become a reason to avoid a film. That is unless he steps a little out of the undemanding comfort zone to do something more interesting, which in comedic actor terms usually translates to dramatic. Let's call it doing a Truman Burbank, as Jim Carrey so superbly exemplified. Now that's not to say The Secret Life of Walter Mitty is any sort of stretch for Stiller, but it's a pleasing change of pace.

The character of Walter Mitty, a name synonymous with daydreaming since the original short story was published many many years ago, is a quiet, still man who is lost in the world. A man afraid to take what is in his grasp who instead finds satisfaction in daydreams where he can become the man he wants to be. Stiller, when not playing the fool, has the ability to exude an everyman quality that makes him both believable and likeable. But at the same time you know he is capable of taking those first steps to improving his life and when he does here it's so wholly satisfying that it warms the heart. The film is perhaps walking a dangerous line between seeming corny and inspiring and you're as liable to perceive it either way. But perhaps I could empathise.


This seizing of the day takes Walter to some cold but highly photogenic places, all of which inevitably look stunning and impart the sense of adventure. But there's also a clean aesthetic to the look of New York and a desire to capture the essence of film based photography and what Life magazine was about. The use of Life as the backbone for Walter's working existence and springboard for his adventure grounds everything with a feeling of purpose. It's a part of the historical cultural landscape after all. The film also benefits greatly from the romantic angle not being overplayed. Kristen Wiig's Cheryl is genuinely nice and the way the two engage continually feels sweet as everything is played at the pace of Walter's nervous uncertainty. It never oversteps.

The balance of drama to comedy is well judged too, with the laughs mostly stemming from the outlandish, effects heavy daydreams. Yet despite their over the top nature they're revealing enough to allow us to empathise. It's fair to say Stiller has done a decent job in the directors chair to make this all work. It's also the most I've enjoyed watching him on screen in quite some time - he just works as Walter. I liked The Secret Life of Walter Mitty a lot more than I was expecting. Perhaps it caught me at the right time but the inspirational nature of the story and the sweetness at it's core are quietly affecting if not occasionally rousing. At another time I might've been more dismissive, but there's something to it and that is easily embraceable.

30 December 2013

Short review: All Is Lost

(Dir: J.C. Chandor, 2013)

In the last twelve months there have been three films focusing on a single character stranded away from humanity. All Is Lost happens to be the best. Life of Pi bored with it's prolonged boy vs tiger nothingness and oppressive piety. Gravity managed to impart the sense of true isolation but in a scenario forever alien to anyone watching. Both relied on stunning visuals to tell and carry the story. All Is Lost feels rooted in a reality a long way from the fantastical and that makes it a more powerful watch. The man in this situation is more logical in his approach, maybe because he's better equipped, but he rarely shows fear or frustration and is able to improvise accordingly. This feels like a lesson in what you should do if ever lost out at sea.


Of course the real anchor is Robert Redford. He carries the film superbly in a near wordless role, dealing with the hand he's been dealt and coping as best he can. He's eminently watchable and helps ensure the film never drags or feels stretched out. The way it's shot enhances the feeling that this could happen to anybody and the storm scenes are gripping, edge of your seat stuff, whilst the loneliness and foolhardiness of heading out into the ocean alone ripples throughout, along with a sense of futility. The narrative never veers off course or gives cause to extrapolate on the man beyond what survival necessitates, meaning All Is Lost never loses itself or feels like it's overdoing things. This is a superbly crafted film that's a great watch from start to finish.

29 December 2013

Review: Anchorman 2: The Legend Continues

(Dir: Adam McKay, 2013)

Let's get this out of the way from the start - Anchorman is the most overrated comedy of the century so far. That's not to say I dislike it or don't find it funny, I'd describe it as fairly funny and reasonably entertaining. It's certainly not the exemplar of 21st century comedy that many hold it up to be and I find the praise lavishly laid at it's feet to be pretty inexplicable. This is one of the most subjective genres after all. When it comes to comedy Will Ferrell doesn't seem to have too many strings to his bow, like Ben Stiller, Jack Black or Adam Sandler. They each seem to have one character they play, just with a different name, set of clothes and scenario in each film. It's variations on a rigid theme and when those characters are only so-so from the get go, it's easy to tire of them very quickly. Ferrell's Ron Burgundy is very much cut of this cloth.

This style of comedic characterisation, playing the likes of Ron Burgundy as the dumb, brash, narcissistic buffoon, has been done so much better in the past. There's no subtlety to a character like this, everything is forced or shouted and exists only on the surface. If we want depth we should look elsewhere. If we want variety, well we have his news crew to provide that and they almost always outshine. Steve Carrell's Brick takes dumbness to a point of interesting, willful obfuscation and Paul Rudd's Brian Fantana may seem like a single-minded lothario, but Rudd is always able to exude charm in the characters he plays. David Kirchner's Champ Kind rarely works however, just seeming too awkward. Burgundy is easily over-shadowed in this company as he's just not that funny. In fact he's pretty tiresome, regardless of how many of his phrases have entered the modern lexicon.

 
The setting of the Anchorman films is a strength as the seventies newsroom offers up the potential for much interest, yet it never feels fully exploited. In the first film this leads to a slightly awkward misogynistic angle to the story, which fits into the context of the era and setting, but are we supposed to find some of this stuff funny or just pathetic? The sequel has moved on from this and instead throws up casual racism which sits really uneasily and the only explanation for this seems to be that Burgundy is just an idiot. This should've been excised as it has no place. But then so should've a lot of elements of the sequel as it more than outstays it's welcome. A meandering story is not helped by nonsense like the incredibly unfunny lighthouse sequence. In a film like this less would definitely have been more.

If the first Anchorman is an OK film, the sequel is decidedly average. There are far fewer actual funny moments and many more misses, whilst it just plods on for too long. Inevitably the side men shine again, as do the cameos, but Ron Burgundy remains a tired and uncreative character that never needed to be brought out of retirement. Admittedly I find Will Ferrell to be a mostly uninspired, generic comedian who is at his best in films like Stranger Than Fiction where there's a sense of thoughtful creativity. If you loved the first Anchorman chances are you'll like this one a lot too, probably just not as much though.

16 December 2013

Short review: The Hunger Games: Catching Fire

(Dir: Francis Lawrence, 2013)

It should come as no surprise that Catching Fire is a better film than the first Hunger Games. What is a surprise is that both of these films have been so damn entertaining. Where The Hunger Games succeeds over other teenage franchises is ideas - there is something going on here that's interesting and almost adult in nature. There's also a whole lot of world-building to be done in the great tradition of science fiction, which this seems to borderline be, and a central conceit that although essentially ripped off from the book / film Battle Royale, works by adding a different cultural spin that feels more relatable to modern times, even if that twist itself has been riffed on for many years. Catching Fire should be a better film as the hard-work establishing everything has been done, so a more developed story can now (in theory) be told.


Whereas in the first film the world-building and preparation was fascinating whilst the games themselves were a somewhat frustratingly drawn out toothless experience, Catching Fire ends up in the reverse position. The weak point of this film is the touring of the "special" couple and the flaccid romance between Katniss (Jennifer Lawrence) and Gale (Liam Hemsworth), but it comes alive again as soon as the prospect of a new games is upon us with a focus on politics and who can or can't be trusted. These games are instantly more interesting with a better premise and a touch more menace, with foes who actually seem like they might be dangerous. Also helping greatly are Donald Sutherland's President Snow, who gets a decent amount of time to snarl, and Philip Seymour Hoffman proving why he is an asset to every film he appears in. Lawrence and Josh Hutcherson remain likeable even if Katniss' brooding negativity gets annoying. At least we continue to have a strong female lead and the romance side of things is downplayed in the second half.

Catching Fire offers another couple hours decent entertainment and like the first film, I'm left wanting to know where this is all going. It may end suddenly but it probably happens at about the right point, and at least the film gets better as it progresses. There really is a lot of story potential here, but having heard from multiple sources what a mess the final book is, perhaps it's right to not hold out any hope for the last two films being as enjoyable.

15 December 2013

Review: Oldboy

(Dir: Spike Lee, 2013)

Considering the reverence with which the original Oldboy is (justifiably) viewed, it'd be so very easy to get into a debate about the merits or otherwise of remaking foreign language films for Western audiences. But that's a tired debate. What is instead worth considering is when a genuinely creative and interesting director decides they want to take on a remake. That gives cause to pay attention and maybe expect a little more. Spike Lee may no longer be quite the visionary he was twenty or so years ago, but his presence always offered hope that Oldboy 2013 might have something to offer beyond tiresome retread. In fact this might've been a remake I'd have otherwise made no effort to watch had he not been involved.

On the one hand it's pleasing to say that Lee hasn't exactly screwed things up, but on the other, I can't see a single improvement in the vision he offers. The original Korean version is an unremittingly dark film, not just in the ideas it has, but in the execution. At times it feels like crawling along the floor of hell in a suffocating shroud of uncertainty. This is one of the appealing aspects of the film. Lee crafts a film that hints at darkness but it never feels insidious - perhaps that's one of the problems of a safe-seeming American setting compared to culturally alien climes. Josh Brolin's Joe is an extremely flawed man, someone needing redemption and direction, but his flaws are excessively hammered home. Brolin plays him well, but there's something almost too obvious about his character, almost as if he's written and played by numbers, a far far cry from Min-sik Choi's masterful performance. In fact the same rings true for almost all the characters. Elizabeth Olson, confident but dark past - perfunctory. Sharlto Copley, strange accent and near farcical awkwardness - a rote eccentricity. Samuel L. Jackson, mean son of a bitch with crazy hair - another variation of angry Jackson. Yet weirdly none detract. It's that kind of film.



In essence, almost everything from the original seems to be in place, but none of it works as well. Most notably the final denouement, which in the original is a savage multi-layered sucker-punch of epic proportions. Yet the remake decides to pare this down to not only be far less complicated and lose some of the point of it all, but when revealing the whole "process" makes far less sense due to too much reliance on chance. Not to mention that Copley's Adrian doesn't convince at all, a much lesser villain than Ji-tai Yu's Woo-jin Lee. For anyone who has seen the original none of this will generate the same reaction, but for those new to the story it will certainly have an impact. Again the same can be said when comparing the corridor fight sequence, one of the most iconic scenes from the original. There it's a realistically brutal and impressively staged fight in one continuous and beautifully tracked shot. This new version seems badly choreographed and lacking menace, like a dated action sequence. Symptomatic of the whole production really.

The remake of Oldboy could have honestly been made by anyone, with Lee failing to leave his fingerprints on it at all, which is a shame, but possibly the result of such strong source material. He seems to place more focus on why this is a flawed man who could be incarcerated for so long and lingers on his time there. Thus the quote "You can't find the right answer if you ask the wrong questions" seems apt. Yet it's a strangely enjoyable film despite it's numerous flaws and it's interesting to see how it has been reinterpreted to be American. This is a film probably best watched without any knowledge of the original, yet I would never ever recommend anyone watch this version first - to do so would be to rob them of one of the most jarring and darkly thought-provoking films of the century so far. Stick to the original, treat this as just a curiosity.